Psychiatry & Social Work Q&A with Kalie Wolfinger
In this first ever live recorded Q&A episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp, Dr. Mark Mullen is joined by Kalie Wolfinger. Social work master's students from around the world submitted questions, and Dr. Mullen answers them in real time alongside Professor Wolfinger, whose clinical and pedagogical perspective offers a productive counterpoint throughout. Topics range from the most common diagnostic mistakes newer clinicians make to the cultural limits of the DSM, the practical differences between the DSM and ICD-11, the Rumpelstiltskin effect and its potential downsides, and what clinician objectivity actually looks like in practice when a patient describes seeing a ghost.
The second half of the episode moves into clinical terrain that will resonate across disciplines: how the DSM does and does not guide day-to-day decision-making, the pragmatics of diagnosing in pediatric and foster care populations, when and why diagnostic impressions must change, the near-ubiquitous role of trauma across all psychiatric presentations, the clinical dilemma of sequencing OCD treatment with trauma work, and how to conceptualize the relationship between substance use disorder and primary psychiatric illness.
In this first ever live recorded Q&A episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp, Dr. Mark Mullen is joined by Kalie Wolfinger. Social work master's students from around the world submitted questions, and Dr. Mullen answers them in real time alongside Professor Wolfinger, whose clinical and pedagogical perspective offers a productive counterpoint throughout. Topics range from the most common diagnostic mistakes newer clinicians make to the cultural limits of the DSM, the practical differences between the DSM and ICD-11, the Rumpelstiltskin effect and its potential downsides, and what clinician objectivity actually looks like in practice when a patient describes seeing a ghost.
The second half of the episode moves into clinical terrain that will resonate across disciplines: how the DSM does and does not guide day-to-day decision-making, the pragmatics of diagnosing in pediatric and foster care populations, when and why diagnostic impressions must change, the near-ubiquitous role of trauma across all psychiatric presentations, the clinical dilemma of sequencing OCD treatment with trauma work, and how to conceptualize the relationship between substance use disorder and primary psychiatric illness.
Takeaways:
- Diagnosis should be a team effort: triangulating across the patient interview, the electronic health record, collateral informants, and input from someone who loves the patient produces substantially more accurate formulations than a single encounter, and comfort with unspecified diagnostic placeholders is a sign of clinical maturity, not uncertainty.
- The DSM was designed for experienced clinicians exercising structured judgment, not algorithmic application; following it mechanically in patients with multiple comorbidities reflects a misunderstanding of what the document is meant to do.
- Willingness to change one's diagnostic impression is not a sign of error but a clinical skill: guidelines explicitly recommend reconsidering the diagnosis when first- and second-line treatments fail, and anchoring to an initial formulation for reasons of ego or hierarchy contributes to patient harm.
- Trauma contributes to negative psychiatric outcomes and medical sequelae in nearly all patients, often presenting as a triad of major depressive disorder, alcohol use disorder, and unrecognized PTSD.
- In pediatric and resource-scarce populations, a pragmatic lean toward making a diagnosis reflects an appropriate prioritization of the clinician's duty to the patient over diagnostic purity.
In this first ever live recorded Q&A episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp, Dr. Mark Mullen is joined by Kalie Wolfinger. Social work master's students from around the world submitted questions, and Dr. Mullen answers them in real time alongside Professor Wolfinger, whose clinical and pedagogical perspective offers a productive counterpoint throughout. Topics range from the most common diagnostic mistakes newer clinicians make to the cultural limits of the DSM, the practical differences between the DSM and ICD-11, the Rumpelstiltskin effect and its potential downsides, and what clinician objectivity actually looks like in practice when a patient describes seeing a ghost.
The second half of the episode moves into clinical terrain that will resonate across disciplines: how the DSM does and does not guide day-to-day decision-making, the pragmatics of diagnosing in pediatric and foster care populations, when and why diagnostic impressions must change, the near-ubiquitous role of trauma across all psychiatric presentations, the clinical dilemma of sequencing OCD treatment with trauma work, and how to conceptualize the relationship between substance use disorder and primary psychiatric illness.
Takeaways:
Diagnosis should be a team effort: triangulating across the patient interview, the electronic health record, collateral informants, and input from someone who loves the patient produces substantially more accurate formulations than a single encounter, and comfort with unspecified diagnostic placeholders is a sign of clinical maturity, not uncertainty.
The DSM was designed for experienced clinicians exercising structured judgment, not algorithmic application; following it mechanically in patients with multiple comorbidities reflects a misunderstanding of what the document is meant to do.
Willingness to change one's diagnostic impression is not a sign of error but a clinical skill: guidelines explicitly recommend reconsidering the diagnosis when first- and second-line treatments fail, and anchoring to an initial formulation for reasons of ego or hierarchy contributes to patient harm.
Trauma contributes to negative psychiatric outcomes and medical sequelae in nearly all patients, often presenting as a triad of major depressive disorder, alcohol use disorder, and unrecognized PTSD.
In pediatric and resource-scarce populations, a pragmatic lean toward making a diagnosis reflects an appropriate prioritization of the clinician's duty to the patient over diagnostic purity.
-----
SUPPORT OUR PARTNERS: SimplePractice.com/bootcamp (Now with AI documentation! Exclusive 7 day free trial and 50% off four months)
Learn more and get transcripts for EVERY episode at https://www.psychiatrybootcamp.com/
For Sales Inquiries & Ad Rates, Please Contact:Sales@Human-Content.Com
Connect with HumanContent on Socials: @humancontentpods
Produced by: Human Content
Chapter: 00:00 Welcome and Setup
00:47 Podcast in the Classroom
01:42 Suicide Case Assignment
03:22 Goals for the Session
04:23 Diagnosis Pitfalls
07:30 Culture and Diagnosis
10:52 Why Social Context Matters
12:26 Sponsor Break
14:31 DSM Versus ICD
17:55 Labels Help and Harm
23:19 Cultural Humility in Psychosis
27:34 DSM in Real Practice
39:59 Trauma Drives Symptoms
47:13 Advice and Wrap Up
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Mark Mullen: [00:00:00] Welcome to Psychiatry Boot Camp. We have a very interesting episode planned for you today. I got an email over the summer from a stranger, Kalie Wolfinger, who is teaching a social work class, and she said, "I'm a fan of the podcast. I'm planning on using it for my class. I'm wondering if you would be willing to come speak to us and provide some insights about how psychiatry and social work can best work together."
And I said, number one rule in academics is never work once, so why not just make it a podcast episode so that everybody can learn from it?" Kalie, is that how you remember that interaction going?
Kalie Wolfinger: That is how I remember the interaction, yes.
Mark Mullen: So tell me how you've used the podcast as a part of this class.
What is this class that you're teaching? Where are you teaching it? and what are you hoping to get through to this hour?
Kalie Wolfinger: Yeah. So I am an assistant [00:01:00] professor at Touro University, and this course is a introduction to psychopathology course for master's level social work students, and it is taken in their second year.
And it is really the first introduction to the DSM or psychopathology in general. And so, I listen to your podcast very regularly as a clinician myself. I've learned so much. And so this summer I was redoing the course a little bit and wanted to integrate more of the podcast, depending on the topic for each module, and that's how I got to my cold email to you.
So thank you so much for being willing to do this.
Mark Mullen: What did integrating the podcast look like? I'm just curious.
Kalie Wolfinger: Yeah, totally. So for example, I think it was last week or two weeks ago's assignment is one of the things that the students had to do is listen to your interview with Dr. Tyler Black. So that was part of the required listening or reading, so to speak.
And then their assignment for that [00:02:00] week was I created a case scenario around a patient on an inpatient facility experiencing suicidal ideation. And the students had to take that case presentation and present to a psychiatrist as if they were in a rounds setting, and then make a video of themselves presenting to the psychiatrist everything they've learned from Dr.
Black's and, your podcast together, integrating suicide risk assessment and then, share how they came to their conclusion, what they learned from the podcast. So it was like a two-piece assignment. So that would be one example of how I've chosen to integrate the podcast.
Mark Mullen: I am so moved by this.
I had never occurred to me that the podcast would be used in this way. I will say that in my practice and in my training, we often work with social workers in this exact same way. A lot of our system functions based on social workers doing an initial intake and then [00:03:00] collaborating with a provider to get to the treatment plan.
So I-- And I also think you picked a really good episode. After I recorded that one, I decided it was the most educational ninety minutes for me. I learned the most in that ninety minutes than any other ninety minutes in my entire life. And I ha-- I've been in school for twenty-six years.
So really good choice. I'm glad you chose that one. And, I hope it was, I hope it was helpful. So in terms of this hour, what's your goal? What are you hoping that the class will learn from this hour?
Kalie Wolfinger: I am hoping that the class will learn whatever they came, whatever questions they came to you with. I have a list.
We have students from all over the world, different time zones, and so some have chosen to send me their questions. So I have a list of those. But I was just hoping that, I would be able to integrate some psychiatry background and knowledge base to this course, considering that my background is a social worker.
I'm an LCSW with a clinical practice, but I just think that, yes, [00:04:00] psychiatry perspective is invaluable for this content.
Mark Mullen: Well, I'm a little offended that you didn't think that I was important enough to have your students awake at two AM- ... in Pakistan tuning in live for us, but I will-- I'll lick my ego wounds and move forward.
Kalie Wolfinger: I'll, post it.
Mark Mullen: Yeah, okay. Let's, let's just dive right in. What do you got for me?
Kalie Wolfinger: I will just start with one that was sent in. the first one is, what are some of the most common mistakes you see newer clinicians make when learning to diagnose?
Mark Mullen: Okay. I think very common mistakes when learning to diagnose, and things that are not often-- One that's not often stressed enough is that diagnosis should always be a team effort.
So I think that it's very tempting, especially when reading something like the DSM and the ICD and reading these different symptoms and knowing that you need a certain number of symptoms and a certain timeline to make a diagnosis. I think the initial read is if you have a ninety-minute conversation with the patient and you present them with these criteria and they meet them, that's your diagnosis.
But I think it's [00:05:00] important to note that when we're talking to people who are suffering, and I'm not-- This is anyone, when you're in a really bad mood, when you're really depressed, some of our patients are even out of touch with reality, right? The way we describe what's going on in our lives, sometimes someone else who has a lot of knowledge about that would describe those things a lot differently.
I don't think we give ourselves enough credit when we're really anxious, when we're really depressed. I think with certain personality pathology, maybe we give ourselves too much credit. So I think that when you're making a diagnosis, you need to obviously interview the patient. They're-- That, that's the most important part of it But it's also really important to use any collateral sources of information that are available to you.
So if you have an electronic health record, making sure you review that. If you have information from public health agency, police maybe who brought the patient into the ED, any documentation of any kind that can tell you about how this patient has been operating in the world, and then ideally talking to someone else who loves them.
And I will just ask the [00:06:00] patient, "Is there someone who loves you that we can talk to?" Or one of my social history questions is, "Who is your greatest support?" "Tell me about your support system. Who's your number one supporter?" And I always think that's interesting because not infrequently I'll get either myself or God.
And I think that's, that always tells you a lot about what their support system is like. So that is kinda, you're in there, and then you can ask politely if you're able to talk to that person. In an emergency, you need to talk to that person. So I think trying to triangulate, get multiple versions of the story so that you can have the most accurate diagnosis is important.
And then things that are stressed but can also get missed, making sure you rule out the role of substances. So even if someone's actively using, you may be able to diagnose a primary mood or psychotic disorder if you can get a firm enough timeline, but often you can't Ruling out the contribution of medical illness, and finally, making sure that you don't feel like you need to jump to conclusions.
I work on consults in the hospital, so we're making a diagnosis after-- I mean, I-I-- [00:07:00] Several times a day, we're meeting someone new for the first time, and we only get to know them for while they're medically hospitalized, not very long. So I'm very comfortable living in that unspecified place, unspecified depressive disorder, unspecified anxiety disorder, psychotic disorder, et cetera.
And I think that can be a really reasonable placeholder while you work to get more information and not feeling like you need to jump to a very firm diagnosis immediately, I think, is a skill that is not talked about often enough.
Kalie Wolfinger: I appreciate that perspective, for sure. Thank you. Next one is actually a favorite of mine.
A student said, "We've talked quite a bit about how culture, social norms, and lived experiences influence our understanding of mental health. From your perspective, how much of our current understanding of psychiatric disorders is shaped by Western culture, and how might diagnosis look different in other parts of the world?"
Mark Mullen: Yeah, that is such a hard question, especially because I've only been trained here in the United States. I mean, I think inevitably people experience psychological distress [00:08:00] and seek or do not seek professional help based on cultural influences. There's a whole, I guess it's an appendix to the DSM that talks about different culture-bound syndromes.
I think in some cultures, acting in ways that are outside of social norms are widely accepted cultural practices, especially in cases of profound loss or interpersonal stressors, and those can serve as important signals in that culture that you are occupying the sick role, the illness role, and that you need more support from Your social support from your community, from your culture.
And I think that here in the United States, when we see certain behaviors that in other cultures would be totally normal, like prolonged grief, for example, really acting out behaviors, externalizing behaviors, they don't fit into our Western understanding of how people should mourn, how people should grieve, how people should act.
And so we may be over-diagnosing folks who are acting in a way that is [00:09:00] perfectly acceptable given their context in the culture that has shaped them. I think cultural psychiatry is so rich. I do think there's a lot of interesting work going on in that space to push the DSM to be more culturally aware and consider cultural influences.
But I think, if we don't think about how the culture that this person comes from shapes not only how they act and seek help, but also, what the relationship of their particular culture has been with the medical system, we're missing a lot because there's a lot of groups of people that have been really directly and severely harmed by Western medicine.
And so when we're going about business as usual, it's easy enough for us to say, "Well, this is what I have to offer. This is how I was trained, and you can either take it or leave it." But I think if you take that approach, what you're missing is that people might have a completely reasonable and a well-founded way to be skeptical of Western medicine.
And so listening to that, trying to address those concerns and making sure that we take them seriously when they bring up those concerns, we're not doing our due diligence if [00:10:00] we're not taking that into account.
Kalie Wolfinger: Yeah, I agree. And I feel like one of the ways that I've attempted to approach this has been through just being pretty direct and honest.
if somebody is coming from a different cultural background than I am, I might share that, "Hey, this is my background and my understanding and framework." And also, I firmly believe that the DSM is just a cultural, social-bound construct. So I would love to hear from you if something doesn't resonate or if you have a different opinion, and I feel like I've learned a lot that way as well.
Mark Mullen: I love that. Yeah, I think just naming directly what's happening between us or the parts of culture that you're appreciating or that you don't know about. I think exposing our own ignorance and where we need to learn more, patients al-always, in my experience, receive that well. they like a humble clinician that's willing to learn, from them, willing to acknowledge what we don't know, which is so much in psychiatry.
And then I think to your point, appreciating that the DSM and diagnosis is one tool, and especially in the social work [00:11:00] realm, one of the important pieces of that tool is making sure that Every aspect of the patient presentation is documented in the record so that higher level decision makers know what they're dealing with when they are distributing resources, making decisions about reimbursement, et cetera.
Diagnoses may not be perfect, but they may-- It's just kind of the way the world turns. So when we think about ICD diagnoses, there's so many ICD diagnoses that don't map neatly to a DSM phenomena, right? Things like homelessness, food insecurity, those are not proper diagnoses in the DSM sense, but appreciating those, documenting those in the record and linking the appropriate ICD codes helps people when they're reviewing the record and trying to understand how the health system is operating to make good decisions.
Kalie Wolfinger: And I feel like from a social work perspective as well, those social determinants of health play such an important role that having them documented is so helpful. The next time [00:12:00] maybe they're readmitted and somebody's reviewing the chart, it gives a much broader context.
Mark Mullen: Yeah, for sure. I think in terms of changing someone's quality of life, naming and providing optimal addressing of those determinants of health is often equally, if not more important as making sure you have a really firm psychiatric diagnosis based on the DSM.
I totally agree.
If you're a therapist and have not yet tried SimplePractice, do me a favor and mark your calendar for Tuesday, November twenty-fourth. That's the start of the Small Business Saturday sale, and SimplePractice will be up to seventy percent off until November thirtieth. I know that the last thing you wanna do after a long day of patient care is catch up on notes, billing, scheduling, and all the other clerical duties involved in making your business run so that you can help humans heal.
That's why I want to tell you about SimplePractice. SimplePractice is an all-in-one EHR that is HIPAA compliant, HITRUST certified, and built specifically for therapists. And if you're just starting out and growing your practice, SimplePractice also has a credentialing service [00:13:00] that helps you get paneled independently.
If you're ready to simplify the business side of your practice, now is a great time to try SimplePractice. Starting November twenty-fourth, get up to seventy percent off, but hurry, this is only until November thirtieth. Go to simplepractice.com to claim the offer. Again, that's simplepractice.com. Very excited to tell you about a new healthcare news podcast that just came out.
It's called Medlines. Medlines is a quick weekly wrap-up of everything in the healthcare field, from breakthrough discoveries and research to politics and medical pop culture. The best way to think of Medlines, it's kind of like NPR's Up First, which I listen to every morning, but it's for all things healthcare.
And honestly, I think a podcast for busy healthcare professionals to stay informed without taking a big chunk of time out of our day is long overdue. Medlines is made strictly by healthcare workers for healthcare workers. Of course, credibility is key for this kind of a thing, which is why it's led by an amazing team, including the great Dr.
Glaucomflecken, Will Flanary, and Lady Glaucomflecken, as well as Dr. Matthew Braddock, who was a [00:14:00] producer of Psychiatry Boot Camp. And I'm really excited to hear his writing for Medlines. The rest of the Human Content Podcast team, who is responsible for Psychiatry Boot Camp, is also responsible for Medlines, so you can bet that it's gonna be an amazing podcast and hopefully a staple of your feed.
Plus, New England Journal of Medicine is on board as the inaugural Medlines sponsor. New episodes of Medlines are out now wherever you get your podcasts, with new episodes out every Friday
Kalie Wolfinger: All right, the next one jumps to what you just addressed, and it says, "We've been learning to diagnose you in-- using the DSM-5, but much of the world uses the ICD-11. What are the major differences between these two systems, and why does the US rely so heavily on the DSM when there's already an international classification system?"
Mark Mullen: Okay, so I am not an expert in this area. I've tried to kind of get into this area in the podcast a little bit, but I've only been trained on the American system. I think [00:15:00] it's easy to dunk on the DSM. I think the DSM has pretty obviously s-some pretty obvious shortfalls, but we do need to give the DSM its due, right?
When DSM-III came out and had excellent inter-rater reliability in terms of what psychiatric diagnosis you met criteria for, that was really groundbreaking. I mean, we had no reliable, systematic way to categorize mental illness so that we could study it and approach it scientifically. And so I think that's why the DSM has such a hold in the United States, is that it was a groundbreaking document.
I think a lot of the ICD stuff is based on the DSM The ICD is from the World Health Organization, whereas the DSM is from the American Psychiatric Association. The DSM, it was designed to operate in a relatively narrow context to make diagnoses, to conduct research studies and clinical treatment. The ICD has to be a really flexible document because it needs to be able to function in every country in the world and in every practice setting that have a lot of resources, that have no [00:16:00] resources.
The diagnoses are being made by people with various levels of training. I think the DSM initially was intended to really be a clinician-- you know, to be used by someone with a good deal of clinical experience. And so there's a lot of kind of abstract rulings that you have to make when using the D-DSM, that the DSM asks you to rely on your clinical experience and your clinical judgment, whereas I think the ICD is meant to be a little bit more universal, is kind of my understanding.
Every DSM diagnosis does have a matching ICD code. Sometimes those don't line up exactly one-to-one, but, in the DSM, there's a specific appendix that says, "If this is your DSM diagnosis, this is your ICD code." And then what I've learned as an attending working in a large health system is there are so many more ICD codes than I had ever imagined because I only trained on the DSM because that's what the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology expects us to know for our board exams, so that's what I had studied.
But now I'm realizing that things like [00:17:00] agitation, suicidal ideation, impaired decisional capacity, those are not proper DSM diagnoses, but they do have an ICD code, and it should be coded, again, for purposes of making the world turn and making sure that we are spreading out resources properly and building systems that actually work.
So I have an increased appreciation for the ICD the longer I practice because I think it's a very practical document, whereas I think the role of the DSM is it's allowed the field of psychiatry to be a scientific discipline and has led to tremendous advances in research processes and therefore the interventions that we're able to offer patients.
Kalie Wolfinger: And actually, back to your original question when we started, one of the things we've discussed in this class is I believe it's the Rumpelstiltskin effect, right? That you- Oh,
Mark Mullen: yeah ...
Kalie Wolfinger: you-- I can't remember which, who you were interviewing at the time. Alyssa Pitt, yeah. Okay. Yes. That was another one that we integrated into the course, and I think [00:18:00] when, for lack of a professional term, critics are hard on the DSM, one of the things I always go back to is some anecdotal experience around the Rumpelstiltskin effect and how much relief clients and patients can feel knowing that there is a language and an understanding for what they've been experiencing, because I think people can feel so isolated and alone, and something I hear a lot is "I'm, crazy," right?
But when you're able to open a book and read your symptoms and realize that hundreds or thousands of people in the world experience the same thing, that alone can provide so much relief, and I'm always thankful for that.
Mark Mullen: Kalie, you should have a podcast. You-- It's a very, good way to describe that.
You're a really, clear communicator. I, think I might've named the Rumpelstiltskin effect the Voldemort effect. I think it's a similar concept. I do think... I think about the Rumpelstiltskin effect a lot. I think it cuts both ways. I think it's ninety percent positive and ninety percent exactly what you [00:19:00] said.
What I fear is that it could be used to externalize feelings and say, "I don't-- I'm not able to have an influence on my life or my internal world because I have this disorder, this external thing that is inhibiting me." And I think that's true. I just-- I think that feeling like these disorders are discrete biological processes that are happening to us don't appreciate things like the psychological factors which could be addressed through psychotherapy that we can develop control over.
So I think... And, maybe what I'm describing is just the Rumpelstiltskin effect gone wrong or people who have a poor understanding of what diagnoses mean. But I think that diagnoses are being wielded in-- on social media, in the popular press, and so a lot of people, even clinicians, don't have an understanding of what a diagnosis [00:20:00] does and does not mean.
And so I do fear, though, that by giving problematic patterns of behavior labels, at times it goes too far and implies to a patient that they don't need to engage on this on a psychological level because this is an external process that a doctor is gonna be able to fix. Do you think about that?
Kalie Wolfinger: Absolutely. And a- as you were talking, I was thinking, that's why everybody needs to be in therapy, because I feel like I spend so much time of my clinical work having these conversations. Personally, I try to be flexible with clients. Something that came to mind for me was, I was processing a DID or Dissociative Identity Disorder diagnosis with a client, and they went home, and they were doing their own research and came back, and they were like, "Nope, it's OSDD."
And we were, like, going back and forth, and then, I think it-- in the DSM 5, it's not OSDD anymore. But [00:21:00] just being like, it doesn't matter, right? what are the... U- ultimately, it doesn't matter, right? what are the areas in your life that this is impacting? And w- like discussing what's within your control, like looking at our sphere of influence, and this is a little bit off-topic, but one of the things I will talk to my trauma clients about individuals who have experienced more significant trauma is unfortunately, you had little to no choice or ability to get out of the experiences.
these things happened to you, right? But unfortunately for you, it is your role to work through how it's impacted you, right? That is your work to do. And that's not fair, but that is where we see the most progress, right? And I s- I think similarly, let's say that there's a biological component to different disorders or, changes like that is [00:22:00] We're not placing blame on anyone, right?
But some empowerment of and also it is you are able to, make changes and have some autonomy over this despite the pieces that you can't control.
Mark Mullen: Yeah. I think that black or white thinking, dualistic thinking is a lot more comfortable for us. That's how we get through the world, I think, is by being really good at black or white thinking sometimes, especially like growing up, you need to be really good at saying, "This is who I am.
This is who I'm not. This is right. This is wrong." But I think as you progress developmentally, being able to appreciate that almost everything is actually not all or nothing or not black or white, and that two seemingly contradictory things are often true, especially in our internal world. And I think that's probably-- I don't know.
I wonder what you would say 90%, that might be too high, of like the journey in therapy, right, is navigating that.
Kalie Wolfinger: Yeah. Well, it's funny you [00:23:00] mention that because if I was in my office, my psychotherapy office, I have a big sign on the wall that says, "Two things can be true." And I will often say this is the entirety of the work that we do in this room, is holding two seemingly conflicting things, that can be both equally as true at the same time.
Looks like we have a question in the chat too. All right. So it says: My question is related to cultural aspects of diagnosing. The DSM-V notes under brief psychotic disorder that we should not include a symptom if it is a culturally sanctioned response. When I think about that, I think about perhaps a culture in which it is normal for people to see a ghost.
I want to know what is the objective stance we have as clinicians, and does cultural humility remove our ability to be objective?
Mark Mullen: I don't know that we have an objective stance as clinicians. I mean, I think this is what countertransference is all about, is that none of us really are objective. All of us do bring our own baggage into the room with us and have our own [00:24:00] understandings of how the world works, how people's brains work, makes-- how we have made sense of our own experiences.
So I don't think any of us are perfect arbiters, and I think that's really important to acknowledge, is that we're, bringing our baggage and we're bringing our own subjectivity. I think it's a really good question, though, and my medical students bring this up all the time. these strange experiences, I mean, seeing a ghost, it certainly sounds like a psychotic experience.
It certainly sounds like a visual hallucination. But I mean, I guess I'd have to diagnose like half of my friends then with having had a psychotic episode. it's like a relatively common thing that people report having happened to them, and certainly in some cultures, it, would probably be more normal to have this experience than not have this experience depending on what it is that happened.
So when I-- And, it often it's, seeing ghosts is a great example. Religious beliefs is another kind of gray area, and maybe these are two and the [00:25:00] same for a lot of people. When you hear something and you think, I'm-- That doesn't sound like an experience that I was aware actually happened.
This sounds like it might be something going on internally that's leading to this experience What I personally do is I remind myself that I have two ears to listen and one mouth to speak. And so I try to just get curious about it and ask follow-up questions and see what it meant to the person, see the stress that was going on around it.
And then, something like seeing a ghost, unless it's pervasive and leading to distress, I don't even know that I would really consider it in my diagnosis or maybe barely even in my formulation. I mean, I think that's a pretty normative experience, after a loved one dies as the best example. so I think it's a really good question.
I guess my take is we're not objective. No one's objective, and these sorts [00:26:00] of strange, unexplainable experiences, you're gonna hear about them all the time when you start to talk to people about mental health. And I would highly recommend a very humble and curious approach and would tend to stay away from pathologizing behaviors if they're not causing the person intense distress or causing problems in their life.
Kalie Wolfinger: I love that, and leaving room for some of the gray, as we just discussed.
Mark Mullen: Yeah, for sure. maybe it is a psychotic-- maybe it's a prodromal psychotic experience. There's a book, The Center Cannot Hold by Elyn Saks, where it's a memoir of a person with schizophrenia who is a lawyer, becomes a lawyer, and she has her first psychotic break.
I should say she has her first episode of acute psychosis, I wanna say it's like college or law school. It happens in the library. But then she talks about, these prodromal psychotic experiences that were a little... She was-- She hadn't totally lost touch with reality, but she was hearing weird noises and feeling more paranoid, growing up.
And so when you hear about a experience like this that is on the [00:27:00] psychotic spectrum but is not frank psychosis, I do think it should sort of tip you off to say, "Okay, depending on the age, the risk factors, et cetera, are we heading in the direction of a primary psychotic disorder?"
Kalie Wolfinger: I feel like I can't count how many times, maybe for the sake of the therapeutic relationship, I might just let something be for the time being, right, and make a mental note.
okay, should we see this again? We'll come back to it, but for now, I'm not poking at this.
Mark Mullen: Hundred percent. Well said. Yeah. Yeah.
Kalie Wolfinger: All right. I'm gonna read another one. how much does the DSM actually guide your day-to-day clinical work? Are there times when it feels limiting or doesn't quite capture what you're seeing in a patient?
Mark Mullen: This is an impossible question to answer All the time, there are times when it feels like it's not fully explaining what's happening in the patient. That is every patient. I think that's a source of frustration for a lot of psychiatry trainees especially, 'cause it's like in other-- in infectious disease, once [00:28:00] you've made your diagnosis, you can pick your treatment, and you can cure the person.
And in psychiatry, you make your diagnosis, and then once you get to know a person well enough, it's gonna turn out that there's a lot of things that diagnosis doesn't explain. So that's every patient where the diagnosis doesn't explain everything. In terms of clinical decision-making, a lot of the role that a psychiatrist plays, in the United States at least, is around medication management.
And I will say, I think medication management decisions should be rooted as firmly on the DSM as possible because that's how the research studies were designed that demonstrated to us what meds work for which problems. So we're always gonna have a DSM diagnosis if there's a diagnosis to be made. Also, I'm an educator, so I'm teaching medical students and residents, and their board exams use the DSM, not the ICD.
So we're focusing on the DSM just for that practical educational piece. So as much of my work as possible is guided by the DSM, but there's so often cases where it feels like the problem that we're really treating [00:29:00] doesn't have to do with a specific diagnosis or that if we were to go with the first-line treatment for the appropriate DSM diagnosis, there would be an external variable that would then be in some way thrown off, right?
It's like I'm thinking of a patient with persistent tachycardia or maybe some cardiac problem that presents with ADHD, and the first-line treatment for ADHD is stimulants. But in this patient, there's significant risks to stimulants, so maybe I can't go with that first line. Or maybe this patient has factors that don't show up on the DSM, like resistance to taking psychiatric drugs or really doesn't wanna take a controlled substance, and so then you're a little bit off the beaten path.
Other things that I don't think are addressed well in the DSM is like when you have-- Well, this happens a lot actually, and this is one of my personal bugaboos. But, you might evaluate a patient and find that they meet criteria for ADHD, PTSD, MDD, GAD, and alcohol use disorder And so if you were to follow the [00:30:00] DSM, so we're gonna start that patient on prazosin, venlafaxine, naltrexone, you name it, right?
Probably a couple more all at once. And I-- that to me, that doesn't really make any sense on like an intuitive level, so I would rarely start two medications at a time scheduled and, I don't think I've ever really started three 'cause I think that's a misunderstanding of what the DSM does, right? Again, it's not like infectious disease where there's three discrete processes and we have three discrete approaches, right?
All of those things are related, and by the way, they're probably all related to trauma. So addressing that, getting psychotherapy involved, I think the mistake would be to say, "I have five DSM diagnoses. The FDA has approved five medications for these diagnoses. You're gonna be all fixed up. I'll see you in a month."
So I think that's a really good question. That's definitely my day-to-day life. I try to stick to the DSM, but There's never a case in which it explains everything.
Kalie Wolfinger: Yeah. I guess I have a follow-up question to that, too. How do you approach or [00:31:00] conceptualize a situation where maybe they don't quite meet criteria for anything?
But I'm thinking specifically with pediatrics. I was involved in, foster care for a while, and so I'm thinking of a handful of children who, there's trauma, there's substance exposure, there's a, a slew of things, and were really struggling in school and, we're seeing, behaviors in a lot of different environments, but we don't quite meet criteria for anything.
Mark Mullen: I'm gonna try to give you the response that I think Allen Frances would give, which is what I typically try to do in my general life. I don't know how successful I am. So I think in children and the elderly, we need to be very cautious making a DSM diagnosis. There's a lot of factors in those populations that need to be considered before a primary psychiatric disorder.
I think the challenging thing in a case like this is it'd be nice for me to say, "Well, I would just leave it unspecified and I would see what shakes out, and I would treat what's right in front of me," which is what I always am saying on [00:32:00] consults to our residents is like, "You may not know the diagnosis and what's really ultimate, the longitudinal trajectory and diagnosis, but what you can do on consults is treat what's right in front of you to help people be safe, treat the acute symptoms, improve quality of life, et cetera, even if you don't know the firm longitudinal diagnosis."
I'd like to say that, but in the case of, children, foster system, et cetera, diagnoses are how the world turns in terms of getting them the services they need. And I'm a pragmatist, so I'm probably gonna look really hard and say, "What is the core dysfunction here?" And then my-- and I, talk about this clinically too, the last question that I ask myself with every patient is: How can I most effectively serve this patient?
And so if I have that patient and I'm a little on the fence, right? Ah, is it PTSD? Well, they don't really meet that avoidance criteria because the trauma's from someone who loves them in their life and they haven't shown any avoidance there at all, [00:33:00] I'm probably not gonna get too hung up on that, Maybe I'm gonna think really hard and- see if I can find an area where that avoidance is showing up so that I can make a diagnosis so that I can help the patient. Because I think it would be a real shame to see a patient who's really suffering and say, "Yeah, you got all these symptoms in all these different domains, but gosh, you just don't quite meet criteria and so therefore I can't make a diagnosis and so therefore you can't get whatever services are available to you in your jurisdiction," which in the United States is not much anyway probably.
I try to be a pragmatist first with diagnosis. I don't know that everybody agrees with that approach, but that's the way-- that's my professional identity as a clinician is to use what I have and the role that I play in society to serve this person. And I think in those cases, leaning toward making a diagnosis is probably the way that I would go.
What do you think?
Kalie Wolfinger: Yeah. I mean, I feel like you are so correct when you say that, the services that kids are going [00:34:00] to receive depends on a diagnosis, and I think I just am very often frustrated with seeing kids not receive the support and the services they need because they don't quite meet criteria in any category.
Mark Mullen: And I do think it cuts both ways. I think that-- I think that the epidemic of autism is probably just that we are being more sensitive in our diagnoses, that people are identifying these behaviors and asking for diagnoses more often and seeking care more often. And I think that there can be downside effects to that on, a social contract, societal level, and I do worry about that.
if we make inappropriate diagnoses and we are unjustly dividing our resources, that's a real problem. If we're allowing people that don't have a disability to use services that should be reserved for that specific population, I think that's a problem. On a one-on-one level, though, I think it'd be an awfully hard life to live if you felt like every [00:35:00] decision you had to make was first and foremost driven by the social contract and making sure every resource was utilized, be- being very granular about that.
I think that on the clinician level, it's really, You have to use a lot of judgment, and your duty is really to your patient.
Kalie Wolfinger: I'm curious how often you find yourself changing your mind or reevaluating.
Mark Mullen: All the time. Oh my gosh, I'm so glad you asked that. Great.
Kalie Wolfinger: Me too.
Mark Mullen: Yeah, this is, this is-- I try to say this once...
my, my life-- I live my life in, one-month increments 'cause our residents are with us for one month. My clerkship is one month. My... Yeah, and I try to say this once a month 'cause I have a different team every month, but I think this is the most important part about being a good psychiatrist and one of the hardest things to learn is being willing to change your mind, being willing to incorporate new data and say, "Okay, this was my initial impression, but now I have more data, and therefore, my impression has changed."
Or even, "Ooh, I might have missed this [00:36:00] upfront, and so I need to change my mind." And I think that's really hard for people to do, especially, in a hierarchical academic setting where someone's grading you and looking over your shoulder and saying, "Are you right or are you wrong? Are you good or are you bad?"
But I think that especially when you're leading the team, demonstrating that vulnerability and that humility and our ongoing learning, and I just think that doctors can do real harm when we anchor to a diagnosis and say, "This is the diagnosis and this is the treatment." And I think it's interesting too that, many, times in, psychiatry, if you look at guidelines and algorithms, the last step in the guideline or algorithm is like, "Okay, and if none of this worked-" Do you have the right diagnosis?
reevaluate your diagnosis. So in a way, like changing your mind is what the evidence says you should do in a lot of cases because it ha- it happens, And even the best of us are gonna miss things, and even the best of us, even if you do your job 100% perfectly, you may just not have all the information you need, or [00:37:00] like in the case of starting a patient with depression on, an antidepressant, you could induce mania in that case, right?
Does that mean you did something wrong? No. The patient met criteria for major depressive disorder. You used the FDA-approved first-line treatment. But now you have a lot more information, and so you better be willing to change your mind all the time. I'm changing my mind all the time, and I think that the number one mistake that I try to teach out of my residents is not being willing to change your mind for reasons of ego or otherwise.
Kalie Wolfinger: I will say one of the most profound things that my therapist has ever said to me was, "You get to be a human while being within this role," right? And I, go back to that so often of I am also a human being outside of a clinician or a professor or whatever the role is, and so I'm going to, even if I'm a clinician, I'm gonna struggle with emotional regulation sometimes or, like we, we get to also be human beings, so.
Mark Mullen: And sometimes you have professional obligations that are really hard on the [00:38:00] human level. Like involuntary treatment is a big part of what I do. Probably 25% of my list on any given time is involuntary treatment. And every n- and usually, with enough experience, you learn that people do get better, and they respond to involuntary treatment and that it was well worth doing.
But every now and then, there's a case where my professional responsibility is clearly to render involuntary hospitalization or involuntary treatment But some part of Mark Mullin doesn't know that's right, And so I think that when you're caring for other human beings, as all social workers really are, there's always gonna be that natural tension between your personal values, beliefs, and, how you think the world should work and what your professional responsibility is in society, for sure.
Kalie Wolfinger: That's where we see the moral injury pop up sometimes as well.
Mark Mullen: For sure. Yeah. I, I think when choosing a job after training, whether it's psychiatry, social work, or otherwise, I think that's probably an underrated part of it is [00:39:00] okay, so there's the salary, and there's the hours, and then there's, could I do this for the rest of my life?
Craig Hickok in Back From The Abyss talks about this a lot, and he talks about, like, when he's training new clinicians, and they're looking at some jobs that have some pretty big numbers and some pretty decent hours, and then you look at what that granular day-to-day work is, and it's would you feel like you did everything you could?
would... Do you really feel like this is your vocation is to do 10-minute med checks 30 times a day for the next 10 years? you might be a good living for your family, and maybe you have to take that job, but there might be a pretty significant trade-off in terms of burnout and moral injury.
I would have to think the social work job market's the same.
Kalie Wolfinger: Oh, absolutely. Yes. I think burnout is, something we discuss in our classes very frequently, and how are we going to prevent that? Or m- now, it's-- I don't even know that it's preventable, but how do we address it when it does pop up?
Mark Mullen: For sure
Kalie Wolfinger: All right, let's see.
okay, I like personally like this question. How do [00:40:00] you think about the relationship between trauma and psychiatric symptoms? Are there times when trauma-related experiences can be mistaken for another mental health disorder?
Mark Mullen: S- so the answer to the second question is definitely yes, and I would say the most common place I see trauma mistaken for another mental health disorder is, and this is like a lot of patients in the world in general, especially in the general medical hospital, is where your-- the two diagnoses are major depressive disorder and alcohol use disorder.
And we treat a ton of alcohol use disorder in the general medical hospital because it destroys your body and eventually it kills you in like a bunch of different ways. And so I'm commonly kinda seeing those two diagnoses, and what I've learned is that it's almost always highly related to trauma, usually with a full diagnosis of PTSD, and that the depression is the negative alterations in mood from the PTSD, and the alcohol is the avoidance behavior.
So I think that's a really common place that I see trauma missed. How do I think about [00:41:00] trauma and its relationship to mental health? I think of trauma as, contributing to negative mental health outcomes and psychiatric diagnoses in almost all cases. I think if you talk to people who are struggling with severe and persistent mental illness and-- Well, I don't know how I should put this.
I think if you could watch a-- If you had a video of their entire life and you asked artificial intelligence to look for a trauma, I think it would find it ninety-nine point nine percent of the time. Does it always cause PTSD? No. I think in most cases it doesn't. But does it have long-term biological effects in terms of your medical health and your psychiatric health?
Absolutely and extensively. So I think about all the patients I see as most likely having a pretty severe trauma history. People cope in different ways. People, I'll say, mask in different ways, but I think it's just so, so pervasive in our society, and I would have to think even more pervasive in places that are not [00:42:00] the richest country on the planet.
So I think it's ubiquitous. I think it leads to negative outcomes. And I guess what I personally struggle with is when and how often to make it a centerpiece of the treatment that we're doing. Because if the symptoms that you're presenting with are not like classic PTSD symptoms, but the trauma is really important in terms of the development of whatever psychiatric illness you have, how is that gonna really change my management?
Like I'm, g- certainly gonna interact with you in a trauma-informed way no matter who you are, and I may approach different conversation topic areas differently depending on what your history of trauma is. But in terms of psychopharmacology or in a perfect world which specific psychotherapy modality I would recommend I don't know how much it changes management where the rubber hits the road in diagnoses where trauma's-- like in non-trauma and stressor-related diagnoses.
Kalie Wolfinger: I think that's why the collaboration is so [00:43:00] important, right? Because I would say that's when maybe it won't change psychiatry's approach, but it will change a psychotherapist's approach, right?
Mark Mullen: How would it change your approach?
Kalie Wolfinger: I am thinking about a couple of clients I have right now who presented with really significant OCD, and any time I am treating OCD and they have also shared a history of trauma in any capacity, it's a little bit of this dance of, my favorite modality for OCD would be ERP, exposure response prevention, right?
But a lot of times I will have clients come in that say, "But I have all this trauma, I wanna do EMDR first," right? And like walking the line and, doing this dance of which direction do we go? And usually my go-to is to do some ERP first because the OCD is dysregulating the nervous system to such an extent that it's really difficult to go back to trauma work, [00:44:00] right, a-and do trauma work in any kind of healthy with pacing in mind kind of way.
And at the same time, back to changing our minds, I've held that view for a really long time, but this last year I've had more clients than not where I have felt like the trauma that maybe triggered the OCD really needs to be addressed first before we can move into more specific OCD and ERP work.
Because I think, even from a epigenetic perspective, right, my understanding is that these traumatic experiences or events can flip on that gene, right? Ugh, it just, yeah, it feels like a really-- such an individualized decision, I guess.
Mark Mullen: For sure, and I think epigenetics are a much more sophisticated way to think about trauma's contribution to psychiatric disorders, so I'm glad that you brought that up.
The mental model that you're describing in deciding which to [00:45:00] prioritize reminds me a lot of substance use disorder plus primary psychiatric illness. And this is just so common. I mean, this is every clinician's everyday decision is, do we conceptualize this as you're drinking because of this problem that you're having, and so let's address the problem and maybe the drinking will get better?
Or are you having this problem because you're drinking a fifth of vodka every day, and maybe if we weren't doing that, you wouldn't be having this problem anymore. And sometimes the clinician and the patient have different ideas about which things should be prioritized, and I think navigating that conversation and getting to a plan that the patient will actually Feel like works for them and want to engage with can be a really challenging part of what we do.
Kalie Wolfinger: I, feel like early in my career, I was really hung up on, is this trauma-related or caused by trauma, or is this maybe more neurobiological? And don't quote me on this, but I believe it's one of Nancy McWilliams' books where she talks about how trauma can [00:46:00] actually change parts of the brain permanently, right?
And so when I w- read that, I was like, "Okay, that's out the window," because again, everything is much more nuanced than... and if parts of the brain are changed, how much do we have control over moving forward? I don't know. It's, just complicated.
Mark Mullen: Especially in the case of substance use disorder, where we have excellent evidence that one of the main areas of the brain that is affected is your ability to prioritize decisions and have executive functioning and decide what comes next for you and seek the things that are important in your life, which for most of us are like, at, the most basic level are, basic human impulses, finding housing, food, shelter for ourselves.
But in cases of substance use disorder, that part of the brain is hijacked, and so people prioritize who to use with, where to use, how much to use, more than where am I gonna sleep tonight. And I see this a lot on consults. It's the same. There is no either/or. It's the same. It's yes, this is [00:47:00] biological, and this is due to substance use.
And so I think seeing them as one and the same is, an important step for developing clinicians. I think we have time for one more question.
Kalie Wolfinger: All right. Okay, this one's broad. If you could give one piece of advice to an MSW student who is just beginning to learn psychopathology in the DSM, what would it be?
Mark Mullen: I think I should start by saying, especially given my tone on the podcast, it is important to know the DSM. I think s-- I think throwing arrows at the DSM and talking about how imperfect it is and how it falls short in helping us to fully formulate our patients is super important, and I love doing it. But I think you have to really know the DSM and appreciate what an important document it is and how helpful it can be before you engage too deeply in those criticisms, because I think for a trainee, there'd be a temptation to say, "Well, it's very imperfect, and so, like, why don't I try to think about things in a different way?"[00:48:00]
and I think that learning the DSM as one really important part of formulation is super important. So I guess I would just start there and say give the DSM its due. It's, a very important and well-done document And then my other piece would be to say, again, make sure you're asking yourself, I guess, the most important question at the end of an encounter or when you're thinking about how you're best gonna help someone, or when you go home from your workday and your patients are rolling through your brain.
I hope that the most important question is not, was I right? Did I succeed? Did I achieve? I hope the most important question is, did I do everything I can to wash this patient's feet to serve them? Did I appreciate what my role is in society and the tools and power that have been given to me in this professional role?
And did I wield those in a way that serves my brother or [00:49:00] sister most effectively? I think keeping your eye on that big picture is super important, and I think it's probably an easier job if you're not constantly thinking about that big picture because it's an awfully tall order. But I think keeping centered on just that service role, and this is very easy for social workers, I think, because I think that you all have a very difficult job to get people the very practical things they need to survive in our world when we have built a society that just simply doesn't offer these things to our brothers and sisters.
I think it's a really hard job, so I-- maybe I'm asking you to do something impossible. But I think staying focused on that big picture while you use the specific tools like the DSM formulation, connection with different social services, is the most important thing.
Kalie Wolfinger: And let's just apply that to all of life outside of our professional roles.
Mark Mullen: Yeah. I think that when you look at your professional role that way, it becomes really difficult to turn it off in other areas of your life, for sure. And you [00:50:00] probably should not. Kayleigh, this was super fun for me. I hope that your students learned a thing or two.
Kalie Wolfinger: I'm reading the chat, and I think everyone is very appreciative.
So thank you for your time.
Mark Mullen: Thanks for the fun idea. Maybe we'll do it again in a few years. And, I'm looking forward to talking to you next.
Kalie Wolfinger: Thank you so much.
Mark Mullen: Thanks so much for listening to this episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp. If you enjoyed the show or appreciate it in any way, I would love you forever if you would leave a review on Apple Podcasts or a rating on Spotify. That really is the best way to support the show. You can reach me with any questions, concerns, comments, et cetera, mark@psychiatrybootcamp.com, and find out whatever else you want to find out about Psychiatry Boot Camp and join our new newsletter at psychiatrybootcamp.com.
You can connect with Psychiatry Boot Camp on Instagram or TikTok @psychbootcamp, and you can connect with the rest of the fun Human Content podcast family on Instagram or TikTok @humancontentpod. There are full video episodes of our show available now on YouTube, [00:51:00] so please check us out there, and thanks again for listening.
I'm your host, Mark Mullen. Our executive producers are Mark Mullen, Aron Korney, Rob Goldman, Shahnti Brooke. Our editor and engineer is Jason Portizo. Theme music is by Cave Radio, and other music is by Omer Ben-Zvi. To learn about our program disclaimer and ethics policy, our submission verification and licensing terms, and our HIPAA release terms, go to psychiatrybootcamp.com, where you can also reach us with any questions.
Psychiatry Boot Camp is a Human Content production.
Hey everyone, thanks for watching. If you enjoyed the show, please remember to subscribe to the channel. If you'd like more episodes, you can click right here. I'd love to connect with you more, and I'm looking forward to talking to you next