NOW AMONG THE TOP 5% OF PODCASTS WORLDWIDE!
Oct. 3, 2026

Is the Gold Standard of Decisional Capacity Assessment Broken? with Dr. Jacob Appel

Is the Gold Standard of Decisional Capacity Assessment Broken? with Dr. Jacob Appel
Psychiatry Boot Camp
Is the Gold Standard of Decisional Capacity Assessment Broken? with Dr. Jacob Appel

In this episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp, Dr. Mark Mullen welcomes Dr. Jacob Appel, psychiatrist, attorney, bioethicist, polymath, and emergency psychiatrist, for a rigorous and clinically grounded critique of the Applebaum-Grisso "Four Abilities Model" of decisional capacity assessment. Dr. Appel traces the model's origins in the 1980s as a patient-empowerment tool, examines how its statutory adoption across more than half of US states has calcified it beyond its original intent, and describes in detail the categories of patients for whom the model systematically fails.


As an alternative, Dr. Appel describes the values-based model, which asks clinicians to identify a patient's current expressed choice, explore the underlying values that have governed the patient's life, and determine whether the two are congruent. He also introduces the consistent preferences approach, which situates capacity within a person's narrative arc rather than a moment-in-time snapshot of intervention programs in their own communities.

In this episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp, Dr. Mark Mullen welcomes Dr. Jacob Appel, psychiatrist, attorney, bioethicist, polymath, and emergency psychiatrist, for a rigorous and clinically grounded critique of the Applebaum-Grisso "Four Abilities Model" of decisional capacity assessment. Dr. Appel traces the model's origins in the 1980s as a patient-empowerment tool, examines how its statutory adoption across more than half of US states has calcified it beyond its original intent, and describes in detail the categories of patients for whom the model systematically fails.

As an alternative, Dr. Appel describes the values-based model, which asks clinicians to identify a patient's current expressed choice, explore the underlying values that have governed the patient's life, and determine whether the two are congruent. He also introduces the consistent preferences approach, which situates capacity within a person's narrative arc rather than a moment-in-time snapshot of intervention programs in their own communities.

References:

  • The Applebaum-Grisso model was designed for patients who temporarily deviate from a Western allopathic baseline.
    Documented racial bias in capacity assessment stems in part from the model's privileging of patients who can articulate reasoning in medical-legal language, systematically disadvantaging those with less social capital who may know exactly what they want but cannot express it in those terms.
    The values-based model offers a simpler alternative.
    Capacity assessment is an intervention, not a neutral evaluation
    In states without statutory definitions of capacity criteria, the values-based and consistent preferences approaches are likely protected under the respectable minority

Irrational People Have Rights Too: Moving Beyond Rationality in Decisional Capacity Assessment: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41801616/ A Values Based Approach to Capacity Assessment: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36638303/Takeaways:

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Mark Mullen: [00:00:00] Welcome back to Psychiatry Boot Camp. I'm joined today by Dr. Jacob Appel. Dr. Appel is a tough introduction for me, to be honest. He's a physician, a psychiatrist. He's also a lawyer. He's a bioethicist, a poet, a playwright, and he's a professor of psychiatry at Icahn School of Medicine, where he's also the director of ethics education in psychiatry, and, he practices clinically in the emergency department.

He's an emergency psychiatrist. Dr. Appel is also the first person I've ever met or heard of even who could not be present for one of his conference presentations because he had another conference presentation at the same conference at the same time. So when I first-- when Dr. Appel first came on my map, it was because of a conference presentation that was about challenges to the current model of decisional capacity, [00:01:00] but Dr.

Appel actually wasn't there because he had another session at the exact same time. So that's my introduction. Dr. Appel, what would you like to add to that? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: No, I, I-- the only thing I can add is to my mother, I'm still her son who's not the rabbi, so context matters. 

Mark Mullen: Okay. Appreciate that. Well, you, belong here.

Let's get everybody up to speed. So we're gonna start by sort of talking about the current decisional capacity model and some criticisms about that model as concisely as possible. Could you explain for me the Applebaum-Grisso model of decisional capacity assessments, often called the Four Abilities model?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Sure, and take a little bit of liberty. I want to explain a little bit about how it arose in the nineteen eighties. It's important to remember that prior to the late nineteen seventies, there was no such thing as capacity assessment in medicine. Capacity assessment was a tool generally used to determine whether people's wills were valid, whether they could testify in court, whether their marriages should be annulled.

Because doctors in a paternalistic model, generally either on their own or with [00:02:00] families, made decisions for patients. So Applebaum and Grisso in the eighties, and other seminal thinkers, Lauren Roth, James Drain, developed models that empowered patients at the time. And the Applebaum and Grisso model, named after Paul Applebaum and Thomas Grisso, its developers, was a model designed to empower patients.

It's only over time that's changed, and their model has four elements to it. First, the patient has to express a clear, consistent choice, communicate what their wishes are. Second, we really need to understand what the medical team thinks is wrong with you to appreciate the circumstances you're involved in.

Third, what I like to think of is you need to appreciate the risks and benefits that each proposed alternative end up doing nothing. And finally, there's a catch-all for manipulating information irrationally. If you start with a certain premise, you come to a logical conclusion based upon that premise. I will add that it's important to note that when they developed this approach, the way they did it was they looked at all of the different state rules and [00:03:00] policies, but they didn't come to an average.

They aggregated them, creating the strictest standard possible because they were trying to sell their approach to a medical legal community that was still fairly paternalistic and fairly resistant. 

Mark Mullen: That is fascinating. So this is the-- We've talked a lot about the decisional capacity on Psychiatry Boot Camp.

It was a season one early episode because decisional capacity assessments are so common in psychiatry and for psychiatry residents. How do you think of the four abilities model as it relates to the standard of care? Like, would you say this is the standard of care and this is the only standard of care?

And then a piggyback on that question regarding four abilities and standard of care, why is this an important question, or would you say it's a question where the importance is overstated? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I think it is a very important question. I think the Applebaum and Grisso model has become the standard of care, but it's also been adopted by statute in more than half the states at this point, or at least elements of it have been adopted by statute.

Some have adopted all, some have adopted portions, [00:04:00] which makes it very hard to reform capacity, even though there are other, models out there that, including one that Omer Merz and I have proposed, that may have benefits over this model. and there are clear flaws in this model that weren't thought out at the time simply because we didn't have that information, at the time.

And now with forty years of hindsight, we understand there are some areas where Applebaum and Grisso works well and some where it doesn't work as well. 

Mark Mullen: So Applebaum-- the Applebaum-Grisso model was first they took a look at the way different states define how decisional capacity should be assessed by state statute.

They put those together, they composed the strictest possible model. But now you're saying that the relationship's actually kind of bidirectional in that state legislatures have reviewed the Applebaum-Grisso criteria, and even in states where previously they had one sort of decisional capacity approach, they've now looked at the Four Abilities model and legislated as such?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yes. I will add with a caveat that [00:05:00] many states didn't have any model at all, so they sort of adopted this on top of a system that was blank where doctors simply did what they pleased. 

Mark Mullen: So you were very clear that the Applebaum-Grisso model is the standard of care. Would you say it's the only standard of care, the current standard of care?

How do we think about this and also hold these other models in our brain? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Sure. So I-- the way I would think about it is the current standard of care, but there are other models, except in areas where the statute prohibits it, where other approaches would certainly qualify under what is known as the respectable minority doctrine, where if enough thought leaders in the field propose a model, if there's literature on it, then it could still be used without risk of malpractice or licensing consequences.

But fortunately, in states where the statute is clear, there's much less wiggle room. 

Mark Mullen: Gotcha. Okay, so let's dig into it. Let's talk about areas where the Applebaum-Grisso criteria has room for improvement. Could you summarize for me a few common criticisms of the Four Abilities model? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Sure. I mean, I think the most fundamental mo- [00:06:00] problem is that it's used beyond what it was designed for.

It was designed to evaluate capacity for patients who at baseline had the same understanding of Western allopathic medicine as you or I do, and that some kind of insult or injury throws them off that baseline. You are sober, and then you become intoxicated. You are lucid, and then you develop delirium.

You are-- have, ordered thought, and then you become psychotic It doesn't work very well for patients who at baseline have a different approach or different standard understanding of medicine or a different value system than the Western world now of how the doctors do. So if you are a Christian Scientist and you believe that prayer cures illness and accepting medication interferes with the efficacy of prayer, you're not doubting the morality of medicine, you're doubting whether medicine works.

Now, obviously, you can't appreciate the risks and benefits approach interventions under that scheme. And yet we let Christian Scientists make their own medical decisions. They have [00:07:00] 3,300 churches. They have a book of prayer and 150-year history, clergy, et cetera, et cetera. So that requires an exception to the model.

The second challenge is the Applebaum and Grisso approach really prioritizes rationality, and it favors individuals who can start with a very simple premise and then using a lot of complex rational thought and often some knowledge of healthcare come to a much more sophisticated conclusion. There are lots of patients who know exactly what they want, it is very consistent with their values, but they cannot explain to you in medical legal jargon or even in philosophical language how to get from point A to point B.

A- And therefore often they have their rights overwritten, and that's the second major concern. I will add, by the way, that there's an excellent article by, Will Garrett that I was a part of that shows significant racial bias in capacity assessment, and one of the reasons I think this occurs is because many individuals who have less social capital may know exactly what they want just as much as people with more [00:08:00] social capital.

They just can't explain it in the terms that modern medicine expects. 

Mark Mullen: I wanna ask some follow-up questions on both of these two criticisms and then see if you have any more. So in thinking about the statement that the Applebaum-Grisso model fails for people who want to make decisions based on, let's say, cultural or religious beliefs, the way that I think about this as someone who uses the Applebaum-Grisso model a lot is in that case, we could consider that perhaps an overvalued idea.

That's not a psychotic thought process, and that contrasts with not being able to appreciate the risks and benefits due to a psychotic thought process, like, "I think the doctor is trying to implant a chip in my brain." So what am I missing? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: You're, basically deciding that you want to apply the model sometimes and not apply the model other times, because when you're saying, "Well, they have an overvalued idea," they're still not meeting those four criteria.

Mark Mullen: They're still not appreciating actually in reality what's going to happen if they- 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Exactly. So either you accept the [00:09:00] model as it's written and then we overrule them, which is not what should happen, I think, or what usually does happen, or accept, I will add, sometimes it does happen when doctors are overreaching or non-psychiatrists apply the model or you don't apply the model, but then you need to create an exception to the model, and you start creating more and more exceptions when the solution would simply be to have a model like Copernicus had for the universe or the solar system that doesn't need exceptions 

Mark Mullen: In our in perfect model, your understanding of the current standard of care is that we apply the Applebaum-Grisso criteria and then make a specific exception for cases of religious belief on that appreciation criterion.

Is that a summarization of what you're saying? I, 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I think that's a good summarization, but we make exceptions for a range of other areas too wh-when it, suits our purposes and when it doesn't. So for example, we sometimes make exceptions when we think the patient has denial. The patient who is an elderly patient who says, "You know, I understood last time I had breast cancer, but this time my back pain is caused by rheumatism."

And sometimes people say, "Well, that's a healthy coping mechanism. They don't really meet the Applebaum-Grisso standard, but it's not like a psychotic idea. We'll, [00:10:00] give them more leeway." I've seen that done. And at the opposite extreme, sometimes we impose the model where we clearly shouldn't impose the model.

So the patient who volitionally is choosing not to speak to the doctors is not communicating a clear, consistent choice. If you apply Applebaum and Grisso, we should be overriding them. But sometimes by not expressing a clear, consistent choice, the patient still clearly knows what they want done, and overriding them is not the just outcome.

It's the easiest outcome, but it's not consistent with autonomy, which is what the Applebaum and Grisso model is designed to uphold. 

Mark Mullen: And then pushing back on the concern about patients who simply are not well-versed enough in medical legal jargon or have a high enough level of education or are a part of predominant Western cultures, thinking about your statement that the Applebaum-Grisso cr- model essentially discriminates against these people, w-what about the argument that's actually a misapplication of the Applebaum-Grisso model?

That in the Applebaum-Grisso model, you don't need to have a firm understanding of medical legal intricacies or [00:11:00] Western values. You just need to be able to explain things in plain English and give your reasoning, and we don't need to agree with your reasoning. To me, I think the Applebaum-Grisso criteria would just be misapplied if you are expecting laypeople to understand things the same way you do as an expert physician.

Jacob M. Appel, MD: If you say that's the case, if you say it's simply misapplied, then it's being misapplied rapidly across the country. 'Cause I think this happens very, often. And a model that has so much leeway for misapplication is concerning in itself. But I also think I've seen patients, and I have been a relative to that matter, who will simply say, "Doc, I don't want this.

I can't really tell you why I don't want it, but it's just not me. I don't want it." And that's a pretty legitimate value, and they can try to come up with reasons to explain why they don't want it, but those are inauthentic and they're giving you an answer, coming up with a rationale for explaining it rather than having a rationale to explain their answer.

Why we would even force it upon people is puzzling to me. In fact, I think more people know what they want and can explain it than know what they want and can explain it in my clinical experience. 

Mark Mullen: I would say in my human [00:12:00] experience, that is often the case as well. So you painted a picture of one patient where the Applebaum-Grisso model clearly fails.

And I have to admit that this is the patient that got me obsessed with kind of some of your ideas is seeing a patient who just won't cooperate for an assessment, and you say, "Well, this is really important, right? If we're going to allow you to leave the hospital against medical advice, we need to know that you understand what you're doing when you make that decision."

And they say, "F you." And you look back at the chart, and it turns out that every doctor they've interacted with for the last ten years, the response has been the same: "Get out of here. I don't want to talk to you." And so I'm stuck because I'm like, ah, seems like there's a good chance this person actually might meet the Applebaum-Grisso criteria if they would sit down with me, but they won't.

So that-- to me, that's the clearest patient where the model fails. What are some other... Are there any other patients that you can paint a picture of for me where you feel like the four abilities model falls on its face? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yeah. and I will add, you can add to that scenario, by the way, we can find from the chart the patient's mother died of medical malpractice when he was ten years old.

So now we even have a rationale for why he might feel this way, [00:13:00] but he's still not saying anything, and often his decision will get overridden. So there are the people with different cultural or religious values. There are the people who won't want to communicate. There are people who, at the opposite extreme, we will allow to make decisions that I actually don't think we should allow them to make because they formally meet the criteria.

So the patient who has-- facing an emergency appendectomy and is nineteen years old and says, "Doc, you know, I understand an appendectomy is important, but I want to go home and feed my cat." They can explain to you in perfect detail the rationale for exactly what they're doing and meet all the criteria.

And yet at some visceral level, letting somebody turn down an appende- emergency appendectomy and go home in the middle of the night to feed their cat doesn't seem like a reasonable decision. If they tell me this is consistent with my long-standing values, they've always opposed medicine, that I can understand.

If they just say, "Yeah, Doc, I just want to feed my cat," much more problematic for me 

Mark Mullen: If I'm gonna follow you and go off-roading here, is substance use disorder considered longitudinal values, right? Like what-- Like in a similar, you know-- I feel like this is where this often comes up is we need to do this [00:14:00] really important procedure, and the patient says, "Well, I need to go and use."

And viscerally, it's like, "Well, that's not gonna work because you might die in the meantime if we don't treat your infective endocarditis." Would you say that substance use can be considered a longitudinal value set? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I think so. It's certainly a longitudinal choice of how one lives one's life. I think we wanna ask questions like, "Has one had a meaningful opportunity to become sober?"

If you were eighteen and had never been put through therapy, I'd be more concerned. But if you're sixty years old and say, "Doc, I wanna go out and drink," that might be your lifestyle choice, even though understanding that there is obviously pathology that leads to that. 

Mark Mullen: Any other patient prototypes that you wanna paint for me that say, "This is why the Applebaum-Grisso criteria doesn't work"?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I'm sure I can give you one more. So they don't really take an interest in longstanding or deeply held value. They don't place emphasis on how long or deeply held your values have to be. So let us say that you are a devout Methodist your entire life, and you come to the hospital because you need to have an emergency appendectomy.

And while you're in the waiting room, the patient next to you, who is very [00:15:00] persuasive, says, "You know, you should really find God and behind the-- become a Christian Scientist." So you do. And then your daughter shows up at the hospital and says, "Mom was always a Methodist until an hour and a half ago." Under Applebaum-Grisso criteria, you have capacity.

Mark Mullen: Right. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: That troubles me too. 

Mark Mullen: Mm-hmm. On a human level, it's like this is just not 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: right. On a human level, that just doesn't seem right. Yeah. Right. And it's sort of a Jell-O jelling question. when you're a little kid, we all know how you make Jell-O. You put cold water in the refrigerator, and you'd go back in five seconds, you put your finger in to see if it was actually Jell-O.

At some point, the Jell-O becomes Jell-O. It's one of those metaphysical wonders of childhood. But it doesn't become Jell-O in twenty minutes, except under the Applebaum-Grisso criteria. 

Mark Mullen: I'm with you. So I'm curious after reading some of your work, just as kind of an honest question here, do you think that, I guess, are you so radical that you think decisional capacity should not be assessed at all?

Or do you think in cases where a patient's desires are clear, should that patient always be allowed to make that decision without [00:16:00] any decisional capacity assessment? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: No, I am, not a capacity ab- abolitionist. There, there are, I won't mention any by name, but I have colleagues who I work with who very much are so.

But no, I think we just need to bring a lot more common sense. But in all fairness, I don't mean to be criti-critical of Applebaum and Grisso. In the world they worked in, they were making an enormous step forward. We just simply have a lot more information now about how this has played out. So I think we wanna simply place a lot more emphasis on values.

We wanna place a lot more emphasis on restoration, which I think has been lost to a great degree also in Applebaum and Grisso process. And we sort of wanna step back and use some common sense and gestalt beyond the specifics of the four criteria. 

Mark Mullen: So I'm really interested in this idea of physician exceptionalism, which you often talk about.

And I think it's true that as physicians we often feel, and even society tells us, that the nature of our work is fundamentally different from the nature of other work. And thus, as physicians, we play by much different legal and ethical rules. And I actually agree with this to an extent. I think that the doctor-patient relationship should be considered [00:17:00] sacred, and that when we engage in the work of healing other human beings, we are engaged in a vocation that is more of a calling than many other, though certainly not all, professions in Western society.

As physicians, we have to make really important, difficult decisions often in an instant, and we need professional ethical guidelines to reflect this specific function in society. For me, one of the gifts of the Applebaum-Grisso model is that it gives us a lot of flexibility in terms of to do what we think is right given our expertise.

Hearing some of your criticisms To some degree, it feels, it's, it feels to me like you acknowledge that we need that flexibility because sometimes our human voice comes through and says, "Whoa, whoa, this is not right." What role do you think physician exceptionalism plays in application or misapplication of the Applebaum-Grisso criteria?

And do you agree with me that we need a model that offers physicians a great deal of flexibility because there is no way to build a model that accounts for all of the various possibilities that a physician might encounter? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: So you've [00:18:00] asked a lot of complex and provocative questions. I'll start with, with the last of them to say that I do think we need a very flexible model.

Part of my concern with Applebaum and Grisso is if applied the way its designers meant, it actually gives you flexibility because most of the cases it doesn't apply to are outside what they thought of as their purview. But it's being applied now by many doctors in a much more rigid way to give them actually less flexibility.

The models that I've proposed and others proposed that challenge it actually are models that are far more flexible. They involve far more looking at the larger picture in the scenario and giving doctors, in some sense, more authority to make decisions consistent with common sense and, human values and the like.

But to follow up on your larger question, I actually do agree with you that medicine is a calling. I don't-- I'm not sure I fully agree with your thoughts on medical exceptionalism. I'd have to explore that more. But I do think there's something unique and distinctive about the doctor-patient relationship.

It is not a business transaction, it is a vocation. I think in some ways it is the-- [00:19:00] I, I can say it's the pollution of medicine with business elements that has led to a more formulaic application of capacity to speed people out of hospitals, to make sure our decisions are medically, legally sound so we don't get sued.

We've lost the time spent with patients to actually figure out what their underlying values are and help formulate best decisions that are consistent with their underlying autonomy. I, would add that the Applebaum and Grisso model, one of its great appeals, it can be done really quickly. A values-based capacity assessment, which is an alternative model, requires a long time.

Mark Mullen: Which to me would be a contradiction with the fact that a lot of the patients where we're saying the Applebaum-Grisso model fails are patients who won't give us the time of day. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yes. There's a paradox there. I acknowledge that. 

Mark Mullen: Okay. The other thing I'm thinking is that as, let's say, experts in decisional capacity assessment, as psychiatrists, CL psychiatrists, we might think we need more flexibility in our model.

But then I think about the grand rounds that I gave to the MFM fellows a few months ago, and I think if you're not working in psychiatry, [00:20:00] you're like, "Can I just have a black and white model? Can you tell me what the four abilities are and I can call balls or strikes?" Do you think that if we were to develop a more flexible model, non-psychiatrists would have even more trouble applying it than they do with the Four Abilities model?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I think the reality is the cases which are more sophisticated are the ones they should be calling psychiatry for. So there, there should be ones where they can apply any model fairly simply. But the ones that allow for a lot more complexity need a lot more time, they don't need to be doing. That's, why I do my job.

That's why I'm a CL psychiatrist. And I wanna, I, wanna follow back to what you said about the patient who won't engage with you. So the Alabama Grisso model, that's a pretty fast case. Right. You just say, patient won't talk, check off the 

Mark Mullen: box. Can't demonstrate. Yep. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yeah. In a values-based model, your goal is to sit with a patient, get to know him well enough so that ideally that patient will trust you and then at least share enough so you can make an informed decision 

Mark Mullen: Okay, let's, stop teasing it.

Let's get into this values-based model. Tell me about the values-based model. Describe it for me. What does this mean? If it's gonna-- If we're gonna [00:21:00] use this instead of the four abilities model, what is this actually gonna look like? And I'll, actually be honest and say I've read, I think I'll call it your seminal paper on the topic.

I've used it once in clinical practice. I linked your paper, and I said, "This is clearly a case where Applebaum and Grisso fails, and we need to use the values-based approach." But I'm really interested in actually in-- like I found it difficult to-- I read the paper and I thought, "Well, that all makes a lot of sense."

And then I had difficulty translating it into what I'm actually gonna do with the patient. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I mean, and I would add it's much more art than algorithm. I'm the first to admit that. I want to emphasize one of the reasons we developed it, beyond simply the fact that some patients know exactly what they want and don't have a way of expressing it under Applebaum and Grisso.

We're also concerned that too many capacity consults are being called in situations where they shouldn't be called. And if you view capacity assessment as a tool, that's not that big a deal. Patient, same as they were before. The reality is, for many patients, capacity assessment is an intervention. A stranger comes into your room, you're intimidated by psychiatrists.

Implicitly or explicitly, they say, "I'm gonna ask you some hard questions. [00:22:00] If you get them wrong, I'm gonna take your rights away." That is not great for the therapeutic relationship. Depending on your background and experience, it can be very damaging to the experience, the relationship. So we want to minimize capacity consults that don't need to be done.

With that in mind, I think the first step in a values-based model is really, simple. You find out what the patient's choice is now. Or if a patient's not making any choice, that, that's a choice as well. You simply document they're not making any choice. The second thing you do is you explore with the patients their underlying values, how they live their life, what their views are on medicine.

This takes meaningful time. You gotta sit down with a patient, really engage with them, build some trust with them. And then you simply ask yourself, where do the two of these match? And if the two of these match, you're done. Patient's value system seems to be consistent with what they're expressing now.

And only when there is incongruity, you want to explore it more. And then when Applebaum and Grisso applies, you'd apply Applebaum and Grisso, or you come up with another model, and there are other models out there that are available for doing a capacity assessment. But that's gonna be a much smaller segment of cases, because in the vast majority of cases, [00:23:00] people may get the right answer for the wrong reason, but it's still the right answer.

Mark Mullen: Does the values-based model then solve the problem in the case of a patient who maybe does have the ability to demonstrate these but is refusing to demonstrate? I guess in my imagination, that was the patient that this model was intended to solve, but I don't see how that person's gonna sit down with you and explore their values.

Jacob M. Appel, MD: And so there are patients who probably are not gonna talk to you at all, period, will not talk to any doctor in the hospital. But there are a lot of patients who will-- In my experience, patients will say, "Doc, I don't want to talk in medical care. I don't want to ask hard questions." "Oh, but you want to sit down and watch the ball game with me?"

"I'll do that." And you chat with them for a while, and you can sort of piece together what's going on. But also, it's important to remember, you don't just have the patient as a source. You have the patient's family and friends as sources. You have the chart as a source, history as a source. The very fact that the doc-- patient has turned down medicine for thirty years tells me a lot about their value system 

Mark Mullen: And the patient's been clear about their choice in the hospital, which is, "Leave me alone.

Let me get out of here." And so when I look at the chart and I see that's how they've interacted with the healthcare [00:24:00] system for the last 10 years, then maybe that's enough of collateral information that I can assess the patient's values just using the chart and make a determination appropriately. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: And the opposite coin, if a patient is always engaged meaningfully with medicine until last Thursday and suddenly stopped talking to doctors, that's a patient you wanna really do your due diligence and figure out what happened and not let them walk out of the hospital.

Mark Mullen: I can see where this model is more flexible now. I can see myself doing this model. I can see myself teaching this model. I can't see my surgeon colleagues buying into this model. Do you have concerns there? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I have some concerns there, but I think I'd rather our service got more better capacity consults or more interesting capacity consults and did a lot more of these than it was done the wrong way.

I think the cases where the surgeons are applying Applebaum and Grisso, which should be applied this way, are the ones that are getting the wrong outcomes, and they're the ones you want psychiatry to be seeing. Because if they're applying Applebaum and Grisso to this case, they're probably just getting the wrong outcome.

Mark Mullen: I see. I see. 'Cause in most cases, decisional capacity doesn't even need to be assessed if it's a clear preference and there's [00:25:00] no concerns. So the only time that a surgeon would even engage in this is where there were significant concerns. And if it's a straightforward enough case and the Applebaum Grisso model works, then great, they don't need psychiatry.

If they do need a psychiatric consultation, then this is probably your preferred model. Is that- Exactly. Am I following your logic? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: That's a perfect, that's a perfect description. 

Mark Mullen: Okay. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I'm not under the delusion that s- surgeons around the country are gonna start doing what I just described. 

Mark Mullen: Yeah, it's actually a simple model.

I think it's elegant, but I do think it gives us a lot of flexibility to do what we think is right in terms of determining what the patient's underlying values are. Thank you for describing that model for me. When we get back, we're gonna talk about how that relates to the current standard of care.

We're going to talk about other approaches that have been proposed, and we'll also, see what defenders might have to say about the Applebaum Grisso criteria. Hang tight

Very excited to tell you about a new healthcare news podcast that just came out. It's called Medlines. Medlines is a quick weekly wrap-up of everything in the [00:26:00] healthcare field, from breakthrough discoveries and research to politics and medical pop culture. The best way to think of Medlines, it's kind of like NPR's Up First, which I listen to every morning, but it's for all things healthcare.

And honestly, I think a podcast for busy healthcare professionals to stay informed without taking a big chunk of time out of our day is long overdue. Medlines is made strictly by healthcare workers for healthcare workers. Of course, credibility is key for this kind of a thing, which is why it's led by an amazing team, including the great Dr.

Glaucomflecken, Will Flanary, and Lady Glaucomflecken, as well as Dr. Matthew Braddock, who was a producer of Psychiatry Boot Camp. And I'm really excited to hear his writing for Medlines. The rest of the Human Content Podcast team, who is responsible for Psychiatry Boot Camp, is also responsible for Medlines, so you can bet that it's gonna be an amazing podcast and hopefully a staple of your feed.

Plus, New England Journal of Medicine is on board as the inaugural Medlines sponsor. New episodes of Medlines are out now wherever you get your [00:27:00] podcasts, with new episodes out every Friday

Okay. So Dr. Appel, in your professional opinion, do you think that this values-based approach currently meets the standard of care in psychiatry? And this is just Jacob Appel's opinion. You're not speaking for, you know, any institution, et cetera. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: So I think in some jurisdictions it meets the respected minority doctrine standard, which means you can do it.

So in, in jurisdictions where there's not a statute that constrains what you can do, which is slightly under half, you are not meeting the standard of care in the sense this is not the majority practice, but you are probably protected from liability and from licensing challenges under the respective minority doctrine.

Mark Mullen: I'm gonna go ahead and ask you this, just since you're a lawyer. I actually didn't know that how to determine decisional capacity was statutorily defined. So in over half of states, there is a law on the books that says, in the routine practice of medicine, when you are deciding whether or not a patient can consent to a particular [00:28:00] intervention, these are the abilities that should be assessed.

Is that right? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yes, and if you are particularly inspired and can't afford trazodone to help you sleep, you can read my paper in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and Law that both discusses the issue and actually has a table of which states require which number of these principles. 

Mark Mullen: Do you have a year on that?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: It's in the last five years, maybe five years ago. 

Mark Mullen: Okay. We'll check it out. We'll try to link it in the show notes. Yeah. That's fascinating. Okay. So in, in less than half of current US states, you think that under the respective minority doctrine, the values-based approach works. You also describe something called a consistent preferences approach.

What is the consistent preferences approach, and how does this interact with the values-based approach? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Sure. So I think at the most concrete level, capacity really needs to be a consistent choice that is consistent with the way you lead your life, with your underlying value structure, rather than at odds with it.

Because if you've lived your entire life one way and there's been no sudden [00:29:00] explanation for change and you've changed, that suggests to me pathology. And the current struc- current Applebaum-Grisso model doesn't delve into that. They simply take you as a snapshot of a human being in a very, "This is where you are today."

I don't think people live that way. people are based on narrative. 

Mark Mullen: Yeah, and, honestly, the-- one of the more soul-crushing things that we do is, can this patient refuse skilled nursing facility placement? And it's like, well, this person's been very clear that they refuse it, but if you're asking me, can they have a conversation with me and demonstrate these four abilities, the answer is no.

So to me, that's the really practical problem that your model solves, and I think that's a tremendous... I mean, just thinking on a macro level, that would be a tremendous benefit to society, in my humble opinion. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I agree. 

Mark Mullen: I've been mildly obsessed with the idea of throwing out the Applebaum-Grisso criteria since my initial exposure to the idea.

And I talked to Dr. Mirza, who you work with on this topic a lot. I've read a lot of your work. Now I'm having the opportunity to chat with you. I've seen a lot of advocacy in the space from [00:30:00] people who agree with you. What I haven't found is a staunch supporter of the Applebaum-Grisso model who is writing and speaking and campaigning to say, "Actually, the model that was invented in, I think it was 1988, is the best model for 2026, and here's why."

Do these people exist, and what would they say in defense of the four abilities model? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: these people definitely exist, and I, won't call out anybody by name, but I am gonna have a column in Psychiatric Services within the year and a prominent psychiatrist on the subject of whether or not Applebaum-Grisso is still the appropriate model or whether it should be reformed.

And a prominent psychiatrist has taken the other side, and I will let him speak for himself when he writes. But yeah, no, I think there are a lot of people who feel like Applebaum-Grisso is maybe not the ideal tool, but it's better than any other tool, that it works, it's transportable, anybody can do it, that if you start getting into values, you end up having psychiatry services get burdened and bogged down with lots of capacity consults other [00:31:00] teams are now doing.

And they get very concerned about the, I guess type two errors, the patients who may get the right answer for the wrong reason, but it's really not the right answer, that you're actually missing some number of people who they have a certain set of underlying values, they're making a choice now, but there has been some intervention that makes their current choice inconsistent with their current values.

I'm not endorsing that view because I don't think there are very many people like that, but I've heard other people explain to me that's a pool of people you're missing. I agree. There may be some people like that. I just think there are far fewer than people who are overriding this way. 

Mark Mullen: I guess one potential solution would be to take an Elbaum-Grisso plus approach and apply the Elbaum-Grisso criteria, and then also apply the consistent preferences and values-based approach.

But ultimately then we'd be working backwards in terms of allowing people to do what it is they wanna do if they can't, don't have... This is a-- This becomes quite circular. This is a tough one. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yeah. I, I think at the end of the day, we want people making decisions that are consistent with their underlying values and [00:32:00] autonomy, and the degree that any model achieves that is a good model.

Any model that doesn't further that, we wanna think about 

Mark Mullen: Dr. Appel, we're gonna change gears here for this final line of questioning and talk more broadly about your role as Director of Ethics Education and Psychiatry. And in this role, you're often teaching, probably leading didactic sessions, interfacing with residents and students.

What would you say is your favorite topic in bioethics to cover with psychiatry residents and students on your service, and why? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Probably the topic I enjoy most because it raises the, the most difficult challenges for them is when people should be able to choose the demographic characteristics to their providers.

Because often the choices people make are inconsistent with their underlying larger values. So obviously, the patient who walks into the ER with a bullet wound in his stomach and says, "I don't want any Black or Jewish doctors treating me," and then passes out, provokes one sense of response from the patients.

The African American psychiatric patient who says, "I want a Black therapist [00:33:00] because a white doctor can't understand me," provokes a very different response. But it gets very nuanced and very complex because there is the male urologic patient who says that he wants a male surgeon because he doesn't feel comfortable with women touching certain parts of his body, and the male urologic patient who wants a male surgeon because he believes men cut straighter.

And how you figure out which is which gets very complicated because once people know the policy favors allowing exceptions for the former, not the latter, everybody will believe the former, or at least will express that they do. 

Mark Mullen: Do most rules and regulations from institutions that you've reviewed allow patients to choose the demographics of their treatment providers?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: So there is enormous variability between institutions. I actually sat on the committee at my hospital, that developed a policy for our institution, which does not allow opt-out except for clinical need for any category except for gender, but allows for reasonable societal-based choices based on gender, which I imagine-- and obviously this plays out.

So I will give you two concrete examples. So clinical [00:34:00] need might be you are the victim of a hate crime, you're in shock, and the doctor assigned to your case happens to be from the same ethnic group as the perpetrator of your hate crime. It might be reasonable to say, in this acute moment, we'll ask someone else to do this if you ask for it.

Mark Mullen: Same applies for someone who's in the throes of acute psychosis, and part of that psychosis is paranoid ideas about race. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Exactly. I was just about to say that. So those would be concrete clinical examples. But it gets more complicated. You have PTSD, as a result of serving in the Vietnamese-- Vietnam War, and you don't want anybody who's of Vietnamese descent involved in your care team.

because obviously the implications of this are not just for you, but they're for providers, they're for the hospital system. You don't want doctors being consistently or providers being consistently stamped with a badge of inferiority because pr-prejudiced patients don't wanna be treated by certain individuals.

So it gets very complicated 

Mark Mullen: So in cases of immediate clinical need, that was the first part of the policy, it can be allowed. What was the second part of the policy? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: So the second part was we at least use a rule of reason for gender or societal based [00:35:00] values, which again becomes problematic. And why should we use societal based values for gender but not for religion or for sexual orientation?

again, it's entirely subjective, but we do make that distinction. So if you want a female obstetrician to deliver your baby, we will honor that. If you want a female orderly to deliver the food to your room, we probably won't honor that. 

Mark Mullen: Huh. And I imagine there's some institutions across the United States where the policy is simply, "Sorry, but you get the doctor, you get the nurse, you get the orderly that's assigned to you, and if you don't like what we have available here, you're welcome to go wherever else you'd like."

I would think that's a pretty common approach to the problem. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: So some places do that, but there are all, sorts of nuances to this. For example, is this an area where deception is acceptable? Where you say you, you want a, a, white Christian doctor, and Dr. Rappel, who is quite Jewish, comes along and says...

You say, "I want a Christian doctor," and I say, "I'm happy to treat you." Have I undermined your rights by not acknowledging that I am, or, is that [00:36:00] such a pernicious request out of context that I have no obligation to share my personal religion? So I love teaching this because the nuances are infinite.

Mark Mullen: Well, I'll say this, I'm glad that I'm not the person teaching it. that sounds awfully hairy. I guess there's probably private practices all over the place that say, "You can pick whoever you want. You can draw it up, and we'll find somebody that matches." 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Right. I point this out. This is a, a, a value that entirely is imposed upon middle class and working class people or the system.

Because if you're, I don't know, Bill Gates or Warren Buffett, you go door to door on Park Avenue until you get a doctor who looks exactly the way you want. 

Mark Mullen: Yeah. Right. Versus if we say, "Well, you can seek care wherever you'd like, and we are the safety net health center," and yeah, that makes sense. Okay.

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Well, what did he at the end of To the France quote? The, "The rich, like the poor, have e- have equal rights to sleep under bridges." 

Mark Mullen: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. all right. And then finally, what's second place on this list? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: second place on this list, I am really interested in incidental discoveries during, genetic testing for [00:37:00] organ transplant.

So we discover, for example, that you're, you come in to give a kidney to your spouse, and it turns out not only are you, perfect matches, but you're actually half siblings. Do we tell you? 

Mark Mullen: I hope not. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Well, we might not w- we might not want you to have kids together. That might have significant implications for your life if you did.

Mark Mullen: Yeah, I revoke my previous statement. I guess maybe I would wanna know. God, that is... Oof. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: And I mention this because actually, so that's a real case from a, foreign country, but we get cases like this all the time where people make... I, always say the, the statistics on false paternity are somewhere between 2% and 4%.

A lot of people are discovering false paternity when they show up to do donate organs. 

Mark Mullen: False paternity is between 2% and 4% of adults in the United States? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Yes. There's a U- University of Oklahoma study. 

Mark Mullen: Wow. And the current approach in these cases is take it to the ethics committee and let the coneheads decide?

Jacob M. Appel, MD: there is wide variation what hospitals do. Baron Lerner had an article in The Sim- The Times a number of years ago now. But there is, I assume there's not become much more uniformity in what [00:38:00] hospitals do. 

Mark Mullen: And what do you think the best approach is? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I think it is very much a contextual one, but it probably errs on the side of disclosure Because for two reasons.

One, because when you think about the kinds of things you'd wanna know that you are gonna falsely believe based on false paternity, like whether or not to get a early onset colonoscopy or whether a relative committed suicide, et cetera, et cetera. They can be pretty significant. But also, I think usually these people are gonna find out anyway if they're involved in the medical system, that somebody's gonna tell them, and they're gonna find deeply betrayed when they find out their doctor didn't- The 

Mark Mullen: information is out there.

Yes. So it's one thing if the information's not out there and only... You can be certain that only one person knows and they're gonna be dead soon, so we don't need to tell anybody. But if it's out there, it's poisonous, and so you have to. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Exactly. 

Mark Mullen: Yeah, that's very pragmatic. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: and there, there's no data on that.

Probably just the N if not too small is too segmented, but I, imagine that most people do find out. 

Mark Mullen: Fascinating. Okay, Dr. Appel. Well, do you have any final thoughts for our audience today? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: my only final thought is for those of you who are not yet bioethicists, I [00:39:00] encourage you to become bioethicists because it's the best job in the world.

Mark Mullen: Do you have anywhere that you think they should train? 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: I don't have a particular program in mind, though I do, I actually do teach, for what it's worth, at Albany Med in Albany, which I love, so that's my little plug. But, the most important thing I remind people is there's an endless supply of ethical dilemmas, so I'm not for- at all worried about competition.

Throw your hat in the ring. 

Mark Mullen: Fair enough. Well, I will talk to you next week, and the listeners will hear from you in two weeks when we record our second episode focusing more on artificial intelligence. 

Jacob M. Appel, MD: Looking forward. Thank you.

Mark Mullen: Thanks for listening this episode of Psychiatry Boot Camp. If you enjoyed the show, please tell us what you think. We greatly appreciate ratings and reviews on Apple Podcasts and ratings on Spotify. You can connect with Psychiatry Boot Camp on Instagram or TikTok @psychbootcamp. And we also have full video episodes of our show available on YouTube at Psychiatry Boot Camp.

You can also connect with the rest of the Human Content Podcast family on Instagram and TikTok @humancontentpods. To contact me or a member of my team, go to [00:40:00] psychiatrybootcamp.com. I'm your host Mark Mullen. Executive producers are Aron Korney, Rob Goldman, Shahnti Brooke, and me, Mark Mullen. Our editor and engineer is Jason Portizo.

Theme music was generously donated by Cave Radio, and other music was by Omer Ben-Zvi. To learn about our program disclaimer and ethics policy, submission verification and licensing terms, and our HIPAA release terms, go to psychiatrybootcamp.com. You can also find us there to reach out with any questions or concerns.

Psychiatry Boot Camp is a Human Content Production.

Hey everyone, thanks for watching. If you enjoyed the show, please remember to subscribe to the channel. If you'd like more episodes, you can click right here. I'd love to connect with you more, and I'm looking forward to talking to 

you next